Skip to content

Sunday Times Teaser 3002 – Short Cut

by Victor Bryant

Published Sunday April 05 2020 (link)

To demonstrate a bit of geometry and trigonometry to my grandson, I took a rectangular piece of paper whose shorter sides were 24 cm in length. With one straight fold I brought one corner of the rectangle to the midpoint of the opposite longer side. Then I cut the paper along the fold, creating a triangle and another piece. I then demonstrated to my grandson that this other piece had double the area of the triangle.

How long was the cut?

3 Comments Leave one →
  1. Brian Gladman permalink

    The diagram above shows the folded corner and illustrates that the fold produces two identical triangles and a set of angle relationships that allow the teaser to be solved. Using the symbols introduced in the diagram, we can see that:

    \[y=s\sin{2\alpha}\]\[x=2t\sin{2\alpha}\]

    Combining these two equations we obtain:

    \[x\,y = 2\,s\,t\,\sin^2{2\alpha}\]

    With \(A_r\) and \(A_t\) as the areas of the rectangle and the cut off triangle respectively, this equation becomes\[A_r = 4A_t\,\sin^2{2\alpha}\]showing that:

    \[\alpha=\frac{1}{2}\sin^{-1}{ \left( \frac{\sqrt{A_r/A_t}}{2} \right)}\]

    From the teaser text we know that \(A_r-A_t=2A_t\), giving \(A_r/A_t = 3\) and showing from this equation that \(\alpha=30^o\).

    From the diagram we can see that\[\begin{array}{l}y&=&s\,\sin{2\,\alpha}\\&=&h\,\cos{\alpha}\sin{2\,\alpha}\\&=&2\,h\,\sin{\alpha}\cos^2{\alpha}\\ \end{array}\] With \(\alpha=30^0\) this shows that the length of the cut line \(h\) is equal to \(4\,y/3\), which gives the teaser solution as 32cm.

    Other lengths are given by:\[t\,=\,2\,y/3\]\[s\,=\,x\,=\,2\,y/\sqrt{3}\] with lengths of 16cm and ~27.71cm respectively.

  2. John Crabtree permalink

    From the areas, 3 s (t / 2) = x y
    From similar triangles s / y = t / (x / 2)
    Eliminating s and y leads to t = x / sqrt(3)
    And so alpha = 30 degrees and all of the triangles are similar.

    From the bottom left triangle, t / (y – t) = 2 and so t = 2 y / 3
    The cut = h = 2 t = 4 y / 3 = 32 cm

  3. John Crabtree permalink

    For the general case, let the dimensions of the bottom left hand triangle be t, t ā€“ y, and k x, where 0 < k <= 1 Let the ratio of the area of the rectangle to that of the folded triangle = R k x / s = y / t = sqrt(R k / 2) = sin(2a) y / t = 1 + cos(2a) k x / s = 1 - cos(2a) >= k
    h / t = sqrt(2 s / (k x) )
    The minimum value of R for a given k occurs when s = x, and the fold goes through the corner.
    4 ā€“ 2 k <= R <= 2 / k

Leave a Reply

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS